Teams 
 | ||
| Name | Years served | |
| ||
| Neil Allen | 2005 | |
| ||
| Joe Altobelli | 1981-82, 1986 | |
| ||
| Loren Babe | 1967 | |
| ||
| Vern Benson | 1965-66 | |
| ||
| Yogi Berra | 1963, 1976-83 | |
| ||
| Larry Bowa | 2007 | |
| ||
| Clete Boyer | 1988, 1992-94 | |
| ||
| Cloyd Boyer | 1975, 1977 | |
| ||
| Jimmy Burke | 1931-33 | |
| ||
| Brian Butterfield | 1994-95 | |
| ||
| Jose Cardenal | 1996-99 | |
| ||
| Chris Chambliss | 1988, 1996-00 | |
| ||
| Tony Cloninger | 1992-01 | |
| ||
| Earle Combs | 1936-44 | |
| ||
| Mark Connor | 1984-85, 1986-87, 1990-93 | |
| ||
| Billy Connors | 1989-90, 1994-95, 2000 | |
| ||
| Nardi Contreras | 1995 | |
| ||
| Pat Corrales | 1989 | |
| ||
| John Corriden | 1947-48 | |
| ||
| Bobby Cox | 1977 | |
| ||
| Frank Crosetti | 1946-68 | |
| ||
| Tom Daly | 1914 | |
| ||
| Cot Deal | 1965 | |
| ||
| Gary Denbo | 2001 | |
| ||
| Bill Dickey | 1949-57, 1960 | |
| ||
| Rick Down | 1993-95, 2002-03 | |
| ||
| Chuck Dressen | 1947-48 | |
| ||
| Lee Elia | 1989 | |
| ||
| Sammy Ellis | 1982-84, 1986 | |
| ||
| Darrell Evans | 1990 | |
| ||
| Duke Farrell | 1909, 1911, 1915-17 | |
| ||
| Mike Ferraro | 1979-82, 1987-91 | |
| ||
| Art Fletcher | 1927-45 | |
| ||
| Whitey Ford | 1964, 1968, 1974-75 | |
| ||
| Art Fowler | 1977-79, 1983, 1988 | |
| ||
| Charlie Fox | 1989 | |
| ||
| Joe Girardi | 2005 | |
| ||
| Jimmy Gleason | 1964 | |
| ||
| Ron Guidry | 2006-07 | |
| ||
| Randy Gumpert | 1957 | |
| ||
| Jim Hegan | 1960-73, 1979-80 | |
| ||
| Tommy Henrich | 1951 | |
| ||
| Marc Hill | 1991 | |
| ||
| Doug Holmquist | 1984-85 | |
| ||
| Willie Horton | 1985 | |
| ||
| Ralph Houk | 1953-54, 1958-60 | |
| ||
| Elston Howard | 1969-79 | |
| ||
| Frank Howard | 1989, 1991-93 | |
| ||
| Dick Howser | 1969-78 | |
| ||
| Charlie Keller | 1957, 1959 | |
| ||
| Joe Kerrigan | 2006-07 | |
| ||
| Clyde King | 1978, 1981-82, 1988 | |
| ||
| Charlie Lau | 1979-81 | |
| ||
| Bob Lemon | 1976 | |
| ||
| Dale Long | 1963 | |
| ||
| Kevin Long | 2007 | |
| ||
| Eddie Lopat | 1960 | |
| ||
| Mickey Mantle | 1970 | |
| ||
| Harry Mathews | 1929 | |
| ||
| Don Mattingly | 2004-07 | |
| ||
| Lee Mazzilli | 2000-03, 2006 | |
| ||
| Jerry McNertney | 1984 | |
| ||
| Fred Merkle | 1925-26 | |
| ||
| Stump Merrill | 1985, 1987 | |
| ||
| Russ Monk Meyer | 1992 | |
| ||
| Gene Michael | 1976, 1978, 1984-86, 1988-89 | |
| ||
| Geo. Mitterwald | 1988 | |
| ||
| Bill Monboquette | 1985-86 | |
| ||
| Rich Monteleone | 2002-04 | |
| ||
| Tom Morgan | 1979 | |
| ||
| Wally Moses | 1961-62, 1966 | |
| ||
| Ed Napoleon | 1992-93 | |
| ||
| Graig Nettles | 1991 | |
| ||
| Tom Nieto | 2000-02 | |
| ||
| Johnny Neun | 1944-46 | |
| ||
| Paddy O'Connor | 1918-19 | |
| ||
| Charlie OLeary | 1921-30 | |
| ||
| Tony Pena | 2007 | |
| ||
| Joe Pepitone | 1982 | |
| ||
| Cy Perkins | 1932-33 | |
| ||
| Lou Piniella | 1984-85 | |
| ||
| Willie Randolph | 1994-2004 | |
| ||
| Red Rolfe | 1946 | |
| ||
| Frank Roth | 1921-22 | |
| ||
| Johnny Sain | 1961-63 | |
| ||
| Germany Schaefer | 1916 | |
| ||
| Paul Schreiber | 1942, 1945 | |
| ||
| John Schulte | 1934-48 | |
| ||
| Joe Sewell | 1934-35 | |
| ||
| Bob Shawkey | 1929 | |
| ||
| Glenn Sherlock | 1995 | |
| ||
| Buck Showalter | 1990-91 | |
| ||
| Luis Sojo | 2004-05 | |
| ||
| Joe Sparks | 1990 | |
| ||
| John Stearns | 1989 | |
| ||
| Mel Stottlemyre | 1996-2005 | |
| ||
| Champ Summers | 1989-90 | |
| ||
| Jeff Torborg | 1979-88 | |
| ||
| Earl Torgeson | 1961 | |
| ||
| Gary Tuck | 1997-99, 2003-04 | |
| ||
| Jim Turner | 1949-59, 1966-73 | |
| ||
| Mickey Vernon | 1982 | |
| ||
| Jerry Walker | 1981-82 | |
| ||
| Lee Walls | 1983 | |
| ||
| Jay Ward | 1987 | |
| ||
| Roy White | 1983-84, 1986, 2004-05 | |
| ||
| Stan Williams | 1980-82, 1987-88 | |
| ||
| George Wiltse | 1925 | |
| ||
| Mel Wright | 1974-75 | |
| ||
| Don Zimmer | 1983, 1986, 1996-2003 | |
| ||
